BRAINBIT
CoursesExamsUse casesPricingAbout
Get started
CoursesExamsUse casesPricingAbout
CoursesLogical PuzzlesWho Did It?

Chapter 1: Truth & Lies

Who Did It?

Solve "only one is telling the truth" puzzles by testing each suspect and by spotting contradicting pairs.

Level 1Ages 10+OlympiadInterview

Explanation

Cookie jar empty

Someone emptied the cookie jar. Asha says Bina did it.

Bina says, I didn't. Chetan says, I didn't.

Only one of them is telling the truth. Who's the cookie thief?

Cookie jar empty. Asha: "Bina did it." Bina: "I didn't do it." Chetan: "I didn't do it." Only one is true.

Table

The sure-fire method: take each suspect in turn, and mark every statement true or false. If Bina did it, Asha is right and Chetan is right.

That's two truths. Not allowed.

Table: suspects down the side, statements across; T/F filled for "Bina did it" → 2 true ✗

Chetan row

If Chetan did it, Asha is wrong, Bina is right, Chetan is lying. Exactly one truth.

That fits, and Asha's row gives two truths, so Chetan is our thief.

Chetan row: F, T, F → exactly one true ✓

Asha says "Bina did it", Bina says "I didn't"

Now the shortcut. Asha and Bina say opposite things, so exactly one of them is true.

That uses up the only truth. Chetan must be lying, so Chetan did it.

Same answer, one step.

Asha says "Bina did it", Bina says "I didn't": they contradict → one of them is the true one

"X is lying" and X's statement

Watch for this pair too: one person says X is lying. That statement and X's statement are always opposite.

Spot a contradicting pair first, and the rest falls into place.

"X is lying" and X's statement → always one true, one false

Worked example

One of Dev, Esha, Farhan, Gita broke the vase. Dev: "Esha did it."

Esha: "Farhan did it." Farhan: "Esha is lying."

Gita: "I didn't do it." Exactly one is telling the truth.

Esha and Farhan contradict, so one of them is the true statement. Dev and Gita must both be lying.

Gita lying means Gita broke it. Check: Dev F, Esha F, Farhan T, Gita F → one truth ✓.

Memory tricks

  • Find the opposite pair: one is true, one is a lie.Ulti baatein dhoondo: unme ek sach, ek jhooth.
  • Try each suspect, count what's true, the right count points the clue.Har chor ko baari-baari aazmao, sach ginno, jawab paao.

Try 3 practice questions

  1. Q1. One of A, B broke the window. A always tells the truth and says "B did it." Who broke it?

    1. A. B
    2. B. A
    3. C. Both
    4. D. Can't tell
    Show answer

    Answer: B

    A always tells the truth, so B did it

  2. Q2. One of P, Q, R stole the pen. P: "Q did it." Q: "I didn't." R: "I didn't." Exactly one is true. Who stole it?

    1. A. R
    2. B. P
    3. C. Q
    4. D. Can't tell
    Show answer

    Answer: R

    If R did it, only Q's "I didn't" is true: exactly one. Q or P as the thief makes two statements true

  3. Q3. One of A, B, C, D did it. A: "B did it." B: "C did it." C: "B is lying." D: "I didn't do it." Exactly one is lying. Who did it?

    1. A. B
    2. B. A
    3. C. C
    4. D. D
    Show answer

    Answer: B

    B and C contradict, so the one liar is among them. A and D tell the truth: B did it

Learn Who Did It? the fun way

Voice-explained cards, mini-games, full practice and the exam round. Free with one account.

Start Logical Puzzles
PreviousIf–Then LogicNextElimination Grids

More from Truth & Lies

  • Truth-Tellers & Liars
  • If–Then Logic
BRAINBIT

Bite-sized, game-like lessons for JEE, NEET, Banking and SSC aspirants.

Courses

  • Inorganic Chemistry
  • Organic Chemistry
  • Physical Chemistry
  • Physics
  • Mathematics
  • Biology
  • Logical Reasoning
  • Quantitative Aptitude
  • Data Interpretation
  • English Language
  • General Awareness
  • Typing
  • Vedic Math
  • Abacus
  • Logical Puzzles

Exams

  • JEE Main
  • JEE Advanced
  • NEET
  • IBPS PO
  • SBI PO
  • SSC CGL
  • CAT
  • RRB NTPC

Brainbit

  • Courses
  • Exams
  • Use cases
  • Pricing
  • About

© 2026 Brainbit. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms & Conditions
Sign in
Get started
Start Logical Puzzles