Explanation
Cookie jar empty
Someone emptied the cookie jar. Asha says Bina did it.
Bina says, I didn't. Chetan says, I didn't.
Only one of them is telling the truth. Who's the cookie thief?
Cookie jar empty. Asha: "Bina did it." Bina: "I didn't do it." Chetan: "I didn't do it." Only one is true.
Table
The sure-fire method: take each suspect in turn, and mark every statement true or false. If Bina did it, Asha is right and Chetan is right.
That's two truths. Not allowed.
Table: suspects down the side, statements across; T/F filled for "Bina did it" → 2 true ✗
Chetan row
If Chetan did it, Asha is wrong, Bina is right, Chetan is lying. Exactly one truth.
That fits, and Asha's row gives two truths, so Chetan is our thief.
Chetan row: F, T, F → exactly one true ✓
Asha says "Bina did it", Bina says "I didn't"
Now the shortcut. Asha and Bina say opposite things, so exactly one of them is true.
That uses up the only truth. Chetan must be lying, so Chetan did it.
Same answer, one step.
Asha says "Bina did it", Bina says "I didn't": they contradict → one of them is the true one
"X is lying" and X's statement
Watch for this pair too: one person says X is lying. That statement and X's statement are always opposite.
Spot a contradicting pair first, and the rest falls into place.
"X is lying" and X's statement → always one true, one false
Worked example
One of Dev, Esha, Farhan, Gita broke the vase. Dev: "Esha did it."
Esha: "Farhan did it." Farhan: "Esha is lying."
Gita: "I didn't do it." Exactly one is telling the truth.
Esha and Farhan contradict, so one of them is the true statement. Dev and Gita must both be lying.
Gita lying means Gita broke it. Check: Dev F, Esha F, Farhan T, Gita F → one truth ✓.