Explanation
Welcome to The Liar's Island
On the Liar's Island, some people always tell the truth and some always lie. You can't tell them apart by looking, only by what they say.
In this chapter you'll learn the one move that cracks every one of these puzzles: assume, test, and throw away what breaks.
Two islanders, A and B
On this island, Truthers always tell the truth and Liars always lie. A says, we are both Liars.
Can you work out what A and B are? Stay with me: by the end of this card set, you'll do it in ten seconds.
Two islanders, A and B. A says: "We are both Liars."
Case 1
Start by assuming. Suppose A is a Truther.
Then what A said is true, so A is a Liar. That's impossible.
When a case breaks, throw it away.
Case 1: A = Truther → "both Liars" would make A a Liar → red
Case 2
So A must be a Liar, and A's sentence is false. It is not true that both are Liars.
A is one, so B must be a Truther. Every statement checks out.
Done.
Case 2: A = Liar → "both Liars" is false → B is a Truther → green
"I am a Liar"
Here's a sentence no islander can ever say: I am a Liar. A Truther can't say it, because it would be false.
A Liar can't say it, because it would be true. If you see it, something else is going on.
"I am a Liar" → red in both cases
Method strip
The method is always the same. Pick one person, assume Truther, and test every statement.
If anything breaks, flip to Liar and test again. The case that survives is the answer.
Method strip: assume → test every statement → keep the case that survives
Worked example
A says "B is a Liar." B says "A and I are the same type."
Case A = Truther: then B is a Liar, so B's statement is false and they are different types. A Truther and a Liar are different, so this works.
Case A = Liar: then B is a Truther, so they are the same type. But a Liar and a Truther are not the same, so this breaks.
Answer: A is a Truther, B is a Liar.