Explanation
Four cards
Four cards. Each has a letter on one side and a number on the other.
The rule says: if there's a vowel on one side, there's an even number on the other. Which cards must you turn over to check the rule?
Most adults get this wrong.
Four cards: A, K, 4, 7. Rule: vowel → even number on the back
"If it rains, the ground is wet." Broken only by
An if–then rule makes one promise. If it rains, the ground is wet.
The only way to break that promise is rain and dry ground. Nothing else breaks it.
"If it rains, the ground is wet." Broken only by: rain + dry ground
Contrapositive
Flip both parts and turn them around, and you get the contrapositive: if the ground is dry, it did not rain. It always means the same as the original rule.
Contrapositive: "If the ground is dry, it did not rain" = same rule
Red
Two traps. Wet ground doesn't prove it rained; someone may have watered it.
And no rain doesn't mean dry. Neither of these follows from the rule.
Red: converse "wet → rained" ✗ · inverse "no rain → dry" ✗
Flip A (vowel
Back to the cards. Turn A, because a vowel must have an even number.
Turn 7, because an odd number must not have a vowel behind it. K and 4 can't break the rule, so leave them.
Flip A (vowel: must have even) and 7 (odd: must not have vowel)
Worked example
Rule: "If a person is drinking cola at the school fair, they must have a token." Four people: Ravi is drinking cola, Meena is drinking water, Arjun has a token, Sana has no token.
Check Ravi (cola → must have a token) and Sana (no token → must not be drinking cola). Meena and Arjun can't break the rule.