Explanation
Resonance
When one structure can't describe a molecule, we draw several that differ only in where the electrons are. The real molecule is a blend of them, the resonance hybrid, and it's more stable than any single drawing.
Resonance: π electrons or lone pairs spread over several atoms · atoms never move, only electrons · the real molecule is a hybrid, more stable than any one structure
+R (donate into a π system)
Groups with a lone pair next to a pi system push it in: that's plus R. Groups with a pi bond to an electronegative atom pull electrons out: minus R.
+R (donate into a π system): –OH, –OR, –NH₂, –NHCOCH₃, –X · −R (pull out): –NO₂, –CN, –CHO, –COR, –COOH, –SO₃H
+R on benzene
On a benzene ring, a plus R group like OH pushes electrons onto the ortho and para carbons. A minus R group like NO₂ pulls them away from those same positions.
+R on benzene: extra electron density at ortho and para · −R: electron density drops at ortho and para
Predict
Phenol or ethanol: which gives up its proton more easily?
Phenol. Its anion spreads the negative charge into the ring by resonance.
Ethoxide's charge is stuck on one oxygen.
Predict: which is more acidic, phenol or ethanol?
Resonance vs tautomerism
Don't confuse resonance with tautomerism. Resonance structures are only drawings of one molecule; no atom moves.
Tautomers are two real molecules that turn into each other by moving a hydrogen.
Resonance vs tautomerism: resonance structures don't exist separately and no atom moves · tautomers are real, separate molecules (an H moves)
–Cl on benzene is −I (pulls) AND +R (pushes) ·…
Trap! Halogens do both.
They pull through sigma bonds and push through resonance. For halogens, the pull wins, so the ring gets slower.
But resonance still decides where the next group goes: ortho and para.
Trap card: –Cl on benzene is −I (pulls) AND +R (pushes) · here −I wins → deactivates the ring · but +R still sends new groups to ortho and para
Worked example
Carboxylate ion, CH₃COO⁻. The negative charge is shared equally by both oxygens through resonance, so both C–O bonds have the same length (between a single and a double bond).
This spreading is why carboxylic acids are far more acidic than alcohols.