Explanation
Welcome to The Electron Market
Organic chemistry is a market where electrons are traded. Some groups push electrons in, some pull them away.
In the Electron Market, you'll learn the effects that decide who's rich and who's poor, and use them to rank acids, bases and stability in seconds.
Inductive effect
The inductive effect is a permanent tug on electrons through single bonds. Electronegative groups pull: minus I.
Alkyl groups push: plus I. It fades fast; after three bonds it's almost gone.
Inductive effect: a permanent pull (−I) or push (+I) along σ bonds · fades after about 3 bonds
Inductive & Electromeric Effects
Nitro pulls hardest, then cyano, carboxyl, and the halogens from fluorine down to iodine. Among pushers, the more branched the alkyl group, the harder it pushes.
−I: NO₂ > CN > COOH > F > Cl > Br > I > OH > OCH₃ > C₆H₅ · +I: (CH₃)₃C– > (CH₃)₂CH– > CH₃CH₂– > CH₃–
Acid strength
An acid is strong when its anion is stable. Pulling groups spread the negative charge, so they make acids stronger.
Pushing groups do the opposite: that's why formic acid is stronger than acetic acid.
Acid strength: a stable anion = a strong acid · −I spreads the negative charge → stronger acid · +I → weaker acid (HCOOH > CH₃COOH)
Predict
Same chlorine, different distance. Which is stronger?
Two-chlorobutanoic acid. The chlorine sits right next to the COOH, so its pull is felt strongly.
On carbon four, it has almost faded.
Predict: stronger acid, 2-chlorobutanoic acid or 4-chlorobutanoic acid?
Electromeric effect
The electromeric effect is temporary. When a reagent attacks a double bond, the pi electrons shift completely to one atom.
It happens only on demand, and vanishes when the reagent leaves.
Electromeric effect: temporary, complete shift of π electrons when a reagent attacks · +E toward the attacking reagent, −E away · disappears when the reagent is removed
Among halogens, F has the strongest −I · FCH₂COOH…
Trap! For haloacetic acids, fluorine wins, because it pulls hardest.
Don't confuse this with HF being the weakest hydrohalic acid; that's about the H–F bond, not the inductive effect.
Trap card: among halogens, F has the strongest −I · FCH₂COOH > ClCH₂COOH > BrCH₂COOH > ICH₂COOH (don't mix this up with HF being a weak acid)
Worked example
Rank CH₃COOH, ClCH₂COOH and Cl₂CHCOOH. Each extra Cl adds more −I pull, spreading the carboxylate's charge further.
Order: Cl₂CHCOOH > ClCH₂COOH > CH₃COOH.