Explanation
Argument = evidence
Every argument has evidence and a conclusion. Strengthening or weakening is about the link between them.
Argument = evidence → conclusion
Ad example
Evidence: sales rose after the ad. Conclusion: the ad caused it.
Ad example: evidence (sales rose after ad) → conclusion (ad caused it)
Weaken
To weaken, show another cause. A competitor shutting down the same month could explain the rise.
Weaken: another cause (competitor closed)
Strengthen
To strengthen, rule out other causes, or show the same effect in a fair comparison.
Strengthen: rule out other causes
Out-of-scope options
Ignore options that are true but don't touch the link, like the ad being colourful.
Out-of-scope options: true but irrelevant
Worked example
Argument: "Students who use our app score higher, so the app improves scores." Weakener: "Only top students chose to use the app."
(another cause: the students were already strong). Strengthener: "In a random trial, app users improved more than non-users."
(fair comparison).