Explanation
Welcome to The Courtroom
In the Courtroom, every statement is on trial. You'll learn to find the hidden assumption, separate what's proven from what's guessed, and pick the action that actually solves the problem.
Argument blocks
An assumption is something the speaker takes for granted without saying it. Without it, the statement wouldn't make sense.
Argument blocks: statement → (hidden assumption) → purpose
Toothpaste ad
An ad says: use our toothpaste for whiter teeth. The speaker assumes people want whiter teeth.
Otherwise the ad is pointless.
Toothpaste ad: "whiter teeth" → people want whiter teeth
Negation test
Test it: flip the assumption. 'People don't want whiter teeth.
' Now the ad makes no sense. So the assumption is implicit.
Negation test: flip the assumption; does the statement collapse?
Traps
Watch for extreme words like only, always or best. 'This is the only toothpaste that whitens' is rarely assumed.
Traps: extreme words (only, always, all)
Assumption ≠ conclusion
An assumption comes before the statement; a conclusion comes after it. Don't confuse them.
Assumption ≠ conclusion: it's needed before, not drawn after
Worked example
Statement: "The government has announced free coaching for poor students for competitive exams." Assumption I: Poor students can't afford coaching.
Assumption II: All poor students will clear the exams. I is implicit (negate it and the scheme loses its reason).
II is extreme ("all") and not needed. Only I is implicit.