Explanation
SN2
In SN2, everything happens in one step. The nucleophile attacks from the side opposite the halogen, and the halogen leaves at the same moment.
The molecule flips inside out like an umbrella in the wind: inversion.
SN2: one step · Nu attacks from the back as X leaves · rate = k[RX][Nu] (second order) · inversion of configuration (umbrella flip, Walden inversion)
SN2 likes
Because the nucleophile must squeeze in from the back, crowding kills SN2. Methyl halides are fastest, tertiary almost never.
Strong nucleophiles and aprotic solvents like acetone help. Iodide is the best leaving group.
SN2 likes: CH₃X > 1° > 2° >> 3° (less crowding) · strong Nu · polar aprotic solvent (acetone, DMSO) · leaving group: I⁻ > Br⁻ > Cl⁻ > F⁻
SN1
SN1 is two steps. First the halide leaves on its own, slowly, making a flat carbocation.
Then the nucleophile attacks from either face. Rate depends only on the halide.
Tertiary, benzylic and allylic halides love SN1, especially in water or alcohol.
SN1: two steps · (1) R–X → R⁺ + X⁻ (slow) (2) Nu attacks R⁺ · rate = k[RX] (first order) · planar R⁺ → attack from both faces → racemisation · 3° > 2° > 1°; benzyl and allyl fast · polar protic solvent (water, alcohols)
Predict
Tert-butyl bromide in water. Which path?
SN1. The tertiary carbocation is stable, the back is blocked, and water is a weak nucleophile in a protic solvent.
Product: tert-butyl alcohol.
Predict: (CH₃)₃C–Br in water → which mechanism, and what product?
Ambident nucleophiles
Some nucleophiles can attack with two different atoms. Ionic KCN attacks through carbon, giving a cyanide.
Covalent AgCN attacks through nitrogen, giving an isocyanide. Likewise KNO₂ gives a nitrite and AgNO₂ gives a nitroalkane.
Ambident nucleophiles: KCN → R–CN (alkyl cyanide) · AgCN → R–NC (isocyanide) · KNO₂ → R–O–N=O (alkyl nitrite) · AgNO₂ → R–NO₂ (nitroalkane)
At a chiral carbon, SN2
Trap! If the carbon is chiral, SN2 gives the inverted product only.
SN1 gives a racemic mixture. Don't answer 'retention' for either.
Trap card: at a chiral carbon, SN2 → complete inversion · SN1 → racemisation (mostly) · neither gives clean retention
Worked example
2-Bromobutane (2°). With OH⁻ in acetone (strong Nu, aprotic): SN2, inverted butan-2-ol.
In water alone (weak Nu, protic): SN1 via the 2° carbocation, racemic butan-2-ol. For 2° halides, the conditions decide.