Explanation
Carbanion
A carbanion already has a full octet and a negative charge. Alkyl groups pushing even more electrons make it worse, so the order flips: methyl best, tertiary worst.
Resonance and pulling groups help it.
Carbanion: 8 electrons, negative, sp³, pyramidal (like NH₃) · CH₃⁻ > 1° > 2° > 3° · resonance (benzyl, allyl, enolate) and −I/−R groups stabilise
Free radical
A free radical has seven electrons, one short of an octet. Like carbocations, it's helped by alkyl groups and by resonance.
Allyl and benzyl radicals are the most stable.
Free radical: 7 electrons, neutral, nearly planar · 3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃• · allyl and benzyl best
Predict
Methane and chlorine in sunlight. What's the very first step?
Light splits chlorine into two chlorine radicals. That's initiation.
Predict: what does Cl₂ do first in sunlight with methane?
Chain reaction
Then propagation: a chlorine radical takes a hydrogen, leaving a methyl radical, which grabs a chlorine and makes a new chlorine radical. The chain keeps going until two radicals meet.
That's termination.
Chain reaction: initiation (Cl₂ → 2Cl•) → propagation (Cl• + CH₄ → HCl + CH₃•; CH₃• + Cl₂ → CH₃Cl + Cl•) → termination (two radicals join)
Carbene
A carbene is a neutral carbon with only two bonds and six electrons. Chloroform with strong base gives dichlorocarbene, the hidden helper in the Reimer–Tiemann and carbylamine reactions you'll meet later.
Carbene: :CH₂ or :CCl₂ · neutral, only 6 electrons around C · CHCl₃ + KOH → :CCl₂ (dichlorocarbene), used in Reimer–Tiemann and carbylamine reactions
Carbanion stability is the REVERSE of carbocation…
Trap! Don't copy the carbocation order onto carbanions.
For carbanions, more alkyl groups mean less stability. Tert-butyl carbanion is the worst.
Trap card: carbanion stability is the REVERSE of carbocation and radical stability · (CH₃)₃C⁻ is the least stable carbanion
Worked example
Rank CH₃⁻, CH₃CH₂⁻ and C₆H₅CH₂⁻. The benzyl carbanion spreads its negative charge into the ring by resonance (most stable).
Among the alkyl ones, fewer alkyl groups is better. Order: C₆H₅CH₂⁻ > CH₃⁻ > CH₃CH₂⁻.