Explanation
Welcome to The Logic Lab
Logic questions punish assumptions. In the Logic Lab you'll learn to accept only what the statements force to be true, and to spot what is merely possible.
Four statement types
There are four kinds of statement: all A are B, some A are B, no A is B, and some A are not B.
Four statement types: All, Some, No, Some … not
"All A are B"
All A are B: draw A completely inside B.
"All A are B" → A circle inside B circle
"Some A are B"
Some A are B: the circles overlap.
"Some A are B" → overlapping circles
"No A is B"
No A is B: the circles don't touch.
"No A is B" → separate circles
Example
All cats are dogs: cats inside dogs. Some dogs are rats: rats overlap dogs, but they may or may not touch cats.
Example: cats inside dogs; rats overlapping dogs (anywhere)
Only what's true in EVERY drawing follows
A conclusion follows only if it's true in every possible drawing. 'Some dogs are cats' is always true.
'Some rats are cats' isn't.
Only what's true in EVERY drawing follows
Worked example
Statements: All pens are books. All books are bags.
Conclusions: I. All pens are bags.
II. Some bags are pens.
Pens sit inside books, which sit inside bags. So all pens are bags (I follows), and therefore some bags are pens (II follows).
Both follow.